One that happens every few weeks or so:
new person: soooo, are you arab? where are you from?
UmmSqueakster: I’m from Wisconsin
new person: ?????
UmmSqueakster: I mean, I’m an american convert. My family has lived in Wisconsin since before the civil war.
new person: ooooo, mashaAllah! So what is your name?
new person: oh no no no, what is your muslim name?
UmmSqueakster: I’m a muslim. My name is Jennifer. Ergo, Jennifer is my muslim name.
new person: no no no, you must change your name when you become muslim. Let me see, how about Aisha? Amira?
UmmSqueakster: Um yeah no. When the vast majority of sahabi became muslim, they kept their birth names. Islam asks us to honor our parents. My parents named me Jennifer, so I honor them by keeping it.